How much time had passed since her first appearance here?
Now, for the first time since their appearance, one of the assembly moved.
I've been there every anniversary since the first appearance, just on the chance.
He is also known to have a great respect for Edward ever since his first appearance.
He has been seen in the background since his initial appearance.
He has scored 8 goals for the national team since his first appearance in 2006.
The highway has not experienced any major changes since its first appearance.
Life had become very uneasy since the appearance of the Count.
She played the character continuously since her first appearance on 12 June 1986-over a year after the show began.
The group had been arguing ever since the appearance of the thing in the garage.