Megatokyo was nominated in at least one category of the Web Cartoonist's Choice Awards every year from 2001 through 2007.

One of the most popular web comics, it won the Web Cartoonists' Choice Awards for best fantasy comic in 2002.

The Web Cartoonists' Choice Awards had an online ceremony as well.

Inverloch has been nominated for and has won a number of Web Cartoonist's Choice Awards, shown in the table below.

Questionable Content has been recognized several times by the Web Cartoonists' Choice Awards:

The Web Cartoonists' Choice Awards is an award voted on by web cartoonists themselves.

Garrity also won the 2005 Web Cartoonist Choice Award for "Outstanding Writer."

The comic was nominated for four awards in the 2006 Web Cartoonist's Choice Awards.

Achewood has been nominated for multiple Web Cartoonists' Choice Awards:

The Web Cartoonist's Choice Awards is an award voted on by webcartoonists.