This new project received a positive review from Q magazine.
It was given three (out of five) stars by Q magazine.
Q magazine called them "One of the biggest bands in the world".
In 2003, Q magazine listed it among the 1001 best songs ever.
Q magazine chose the band as one of their acts to look out for in 2005.
Q magazine proclaimed it the 22nd best album of 2005.
Its most notable review was a four star rating in Q magazine.
Q Magazine were also more critical, awarding 2 stars out of 5.
Q magazine ranked it as the 11th best album of the decade.
It also got four stars from Q magazine, although the review found the name of the album "awful".