Outer Critics Circle Award (2009)

Outer Critics Circle Award for Outstanding Performance (Reynolds, winner)

Outer Critics Circle Awards (nominations)

Outer Critics Circle Award (2000) - The Wild Party (winner)

Outer Critics Circle Citation for Sustained Excellence (1995)

Outer Critics Circle Award for Best Actor in a Musical (1988)

Outer Critics Circle Award for Best Broadway Play (winner)

Outer Critics Circle Award nominations (no wins):

Outer Critics Award Show Boat (1997)

Outer Critics Circle Award for Best Actress (winner)