The catch was named the top post-season moment in the 5th annual This Year in Baseball Awards.

This Year in Baseball Awards (including Rookie)

Many of the awards for 2002-present are listed at This Year in Baseball Awards (Baseball-Almanac.com)

Most of the awards for 2002-2009 are listed at This Year in Baseball Awards (HickokSports.com)

This Year in Baseball Awards (including hitter)

This Year in Baseball Awards (including manager)

This Year in Baseball Awards (including Starting Pitcher, Setup Pitcher, and Closer)

In MLB.com's This Year in Baseball Awards, he was chosen as the top starter in 2006 season with more than 47% of the fan vote.

MLB "This Year in Baseball Awards"

He was voted by fans as MLB "This Year in Baseball Awards" Manager of the Year.