square shooter
straight shooter
straight arrow

And suddenly he's a straight arrow for the last couple of years.

They like players who are straight arrows and believe in hard work.

The mark will be in panic, especially if he/she is a straight arrow.

He's a straight arrow who practically gets no credit at all.

There was absolutely no reason why I shouldn't be straight arrow and honest with them.

He comes on as a straight arrow, not a bully.

He's a straight arrow and I would expect the best from him.

The third row has a simple straight arrow pointing to the left.

She's pretty enough, but she comes off as a straight arrow.

He was then, and still is, the quintessential straight arrow.