To avoid a disagreement and a new trial, a compromise verdict was arrived at.
Lawyers for the city, Patricia Miller and Frank M. Esposito, both said they saw the low damages as a compromise verdict.
A jury sentenced McCoy on a compromise verdict of manslaughter.
His mother, Carol DiPaolo, saw the jury's action as a "compromise" verdict because "it's easier to find an institution liable and not a person."
That request was an obvious effort to forestall a compromise verdict.
Ever since the prosecutors added the new perjury counts in March, the defense has been presented with the risk of a compromise verdict.
But the defense, taking a major gamble, rejected not only a plea bargain but also the idea of a compromise verdict of manslaughter.
In what is believed to have been a compromise verdict, McCoy was convicted of manslaughter.
Jurors disputed an inference that manslaughter may have been a compromise verdict.
By midafternoon on the third day, the debate over a compromise verdict of manslaughter had become testy, and several positions had hardened.